Your Cards, Our Vault

Secure Submissions

Shipping instructions

Ensure you fill out and print your submission sheet, and include that in your packaging. The submission sheet is below.

1.) Place each card individually inside a penny sleeve, and then into an appropriate toploader or semi-rigid holder.

2.) Place ding defenders or cardboard on all sides of your cards and bound them together with a rubber band or some painter's tape.

3.) Choose a sturdy box with a tight fit for your cards to ensure minimal movement during transit. Any open space inside the box should be filled with packing paper or bubble wrap.

4.) Tape the box up securely, and purchase a shipping label from your local post office or an online service, and place the label on the box. (Shipping address listed below)

5.) Take the box to a respective drop off point or send through the mail, and let the anticipation begin!

Shipping Address: Blue Star Grading 533 Bones Branch Road Phelps, KY 41553

Print your submission sheet!

Get in Touch

Submission Inquiries

For questions regarding your submission status, tracking, or general support, please complete the form below. All insured packages should be sent to our secure receiving vault:

Blue Star Card Grading
cardgradinginc@yahoo.com 502-542-3884

Before You Ship

Packaging Essentials

Proper packaging protects your cards during transit. Follow these steps to ensure they arrive safely and ready for grading.

Clean Surface

Penny Sleeve

Card Saver 1

Remove all dust and fingerprints with a clean, dry microfiber cloth. A pristine surface is key to accurate grading.

Each card must be placed in a new, clear penny sleeve. This prevents surface scratches and edge wear.

Insert sleeved cards into semi-rigid Card Saver 1 holders. This provides crucial structural protection.